On occasion I have the opportunity to sit down with social justice advocates as they discuss and then put into action educational and advocacy efforts, processes, and the changing of the system. For the record, I just nod in approval.
One of these discussions turned to advance directives. These instructions, usually given to medical personnel when a dying person is incapacitated, can reduce suffering, increase peace of mind, and give people control over how they want to be handled leading up to death. Also, these orders drastically reduce the chance of letting the person slip into a persistent vegetative state (PVS), and we know how that sometime turns out.
Anyone who has witnessed a person who can no longer communicate, groans from intense pain, has liquid, food, and oxygen forced down tubes in the mouth and nose, and has organs shutting down, knows the correct moral decision.
People who want to diminish the dying person’s wish because of some misguided religious notion needs to think about the stress and financial burden on the family, hospital, and community. Hospitals can go bankrupt and put people out of jobs because of the great costs. Money to help the curable is lost forever.
While the advancement of medical technology has literally put a face on fetuses, it also has clearly defined PVS. Even with that said, end of life issues are complicated and will have to be decided by a diverse coalition of rational and educated people, and out of the hands of ideologues and those with personal agendas. That is why it was sad to see Bill Frist, a supposedly intelligent person with vast health experience, not lead a national debate that could have come up with meaningful solutions.
Anyway, during this discussion, one scenario presented was how would Christian conservatives react to the situation of an undocumented immigrant in a PVS and a family in Mexico with no money to care for him but wanting him kept alive at all cost. While the responses paralleled the compassion of those in attendance, my own level of tolerance toward conservative philosophy remains very low. Personally, I think right-wingers would roll the poor guy over the border bridge while hoping that he would fall into the river.